Alright.
My sentiments on the Chik-fil-A debacle:
-Everyone. Calm the HELL down.
-Personally, I wish that everyone liked each other, and respected each other's views. While I'm at it, I'd also like a pony and Venezuela.
-That said, that would be really boring. You get the most interesting things from the edge of conflict. The desire of something that's impossible can make possible the improbable.
-The main problem with both sides of this issue is that we don't want to be tolerant anymore; we want to be *right*. And we want the other side to admit it. And maybe grovel for a few years. It's the human condition to be an overbearing jerk.
-The idea of free speech is being dramatically overplayed here. While I have the freedom to say one thing, everyone else has that same freedom to disagree with me publically. The line is drawn where we start actually becoming a menace to society: like if I yelled "Fire!" in a theater. Because that creates more conflict. Don't bitch about free speech and then turn around and tell me that I can't say what *I* think, because that isn't how the world works. It's at such a point of conflict right now that it's essentially a non-issue, because it feels like everyone this thing has the same opinion on it. And I'm pretty sure that opinion is "I do what I want."
-I believe in gay marriage. I believe in free speech. I believe in a lot of things. I also believe that my moral stance has NOTHING to do with what I use my wallet for. I am a college student. I work so that I can afford school. If the food that I eat happens to come from somewhere that is run by a person whose opinion doesn't align with mine, I. Don't. Care. If that makes me a hypocrite, then so be it, but I am not at the point in my life where I can afford to care where my 5 dollars are going.
-That said, I've actually never heard of chik fil a before this past two weeks. Every time you protest something, you run the risk of giving it the "underdog image". And people love the idea of championing the underdog.
-But really, my main point is:
Everyone. Calm the Hell Down.
-I welcome responsible comments and discussion.
My definition of responsible is subject to the cruel whims of whichever book I happen to be reading at the time, but feel free to play the lottery and tell me why I'm wrong. Or right.
Showing posts with label free speech. Show all posts
Showing posts with label free speech. Show all posts
03 August 2012
17 February 2011
Free Speech is Not a Suggestion
So. Let's play a game of pretend.
*
You're a teacher, regular public school. You get paid an average wage for doing an incredible job - you teach children. You have gone to school for a certain number of years expressly to do this job. You enjoy teaching - since you sure as hell can't enjoy the money that you get out of it.
But the problem is some kids don't enjoy learning. Or don't think it's important. Or are too damn lazy to do the work.
Admittedly, in a lot of cases, it falls to you, the teacher, to make class more interesting for these kids. But maybe the kids don't care. Maybe the only way to get your kids to pay attention is to come in dressed as a giant clown.
Maybe you don't own a clown costume.
More seriously, what if the parents don't care? What if the kid comes to your class, sits in the back, slouches, scribbles odd things all over the desk, (oh yes, you know this kid. You might have been this kid.) gets into fights, refuses to turn in the homework. What if the kid, yeah, sits up front... but only does that to be closer to the exit? What if the kid paints her - or his - nails, and you are *sick* and *tired* of getting a migraine from the smell everyday?
And this kid comes to your classes, listens (or doesn't) to this talk about how education is important... and then goes home and listens to how it isn't.
Or turns on the TV to find out that Our Government obviously doesn't think it's all that important.
And that's just the classes. Afterwards, you get to go through the homework. Check the answers. Figure out the grading system - which gets more complex every year.
In the cases of a lot of teachers that I have had, this will take you until at least 6 pm every weekday.
So you're a teacher. Got a tough, nearly impossible job for half the year on abysmal pay. How do you work out frustrations? You could rant to people.
*
I rant to people. My friends rant to people. I think it's one of the healthiest ways of dealing with frustration, stress, and anger ever. But apparently the school district of Central Bucks East High School doesn't believe in this... or free speech.
For a state that gave birth to John Dickinson, 1765 author of The Declaration of Rights and Grievances, and the first two Continental Congresses, Pennsylvania is remarkably torn on the issue of Natalie Munroe, a high school teacher who was escorted out of the school after a parent posted on Facebook a blog post that Munroe had written about her job.
"Of my 84 blogs, 60 of them had absolutely nothing to do with school or work. Of the 24 that mentioned it, only some of them were actually focused on it--others may have mentioned it in passing, like if I was listing things that annoyed me that day and wrote without any elaboration that students were annoying that day." Where are we going & why are we in this handbasket: Bloggate
In a country that has a multitude of IP addresses, emails, blogs, computer systems, surely it isn't a surprise to find out that a few teachers have blogs...and, god forbid, have blogged about their students?
One need only look at my facebook page to find comments much more sarcastic...and much more profane than the comments Munroe posted on her blog. (No, I won't give you the link. Check your own facebook.) In addition, I will freely name places, people, and events, and I'll probably post links to things that piss me off.
Natalie Munroe blogged under the name "Natalie M", mentioned no students by name, didn't mention her school...but remains suspended from teaching as the Internet debates rage on.
I'm coming back to teaching issues later this...week...(Jeez, it's already Thursday) because in Wisconsin, there's another issue that's even nearer and dearer to my heart. And eventually I'll comment on how not only are we making war on two fronts at once, but one of those fronts is a concept. And how this takes money away from making your children almost bearable.
*
You're a teacher, regular public school. You get paid an average wage for doing an incredible job - you teach children. You have gone to school for a certain number of years expressly to do this job. You enjoy teaching - since you sure as hell can't enjoy the money that you get out of it.
But the problem is some kids don't enjoy learning. Or don't think it's important. Or are too damn lazy to do the work.
Admittedly, in a lot of cases, it falls to you, the teacher, to make class more interesting for these kids. But maybe the kids don't care. Maybe the only way to get your kids to pay attention is to come in dressed as a giant clown.
Maybe you don't own a clown costume.
More seriously, what if the parents don't care? What if the kid comes to your class, sits in the back, slouches, scribbles odd things all over the desk, (oh yes, you know this kid. You might have been this kid.) gets into fights, refuses to turn in the homework. What if the kid, yeah, sits up front... but only does that to be closer to the exit? What if the kid paints her - or his - nails, and you are *sick* and *tired* of getting a migraine from the smell everyday?
And this kid comes to your classes, listens (or doesn't) to this talk about how education is important... and then goes home and listens to how it isn't.
Or turns on the TV to find out that Our Government obviously doesn't think it's all that important.
And that's just the classes. Afterwards, you get to go through the homework. Check the answers. Figure out the grading system - which gets more complex every year.
In the cases of a lot of teachers that I have had, this will take you until at least 6 pm every weekday.
So you're a teacher. Got a tough, nearly impossible job for half the year on abysmal pay. How do you work out frustrations? You could rant to people.
*
I rant to people. My friends rant to people. I think it's one of the healthiest ways of dealing with frustration, stress, and anger ever. But apparently the school district of Central Bucks East High School doesn't believe in this... or free speech.
For a state that gave birth to John Dickinson, 1765 author of The Declaration of Rights and Grievances, and the first two Continental Congresses, Pennsylvania is remarkably torn on the issue of Natalie Munroe, a high school teacher who was escorted out of the school after a parent posted on Facebook a blog post that Munroe had written about her job.
"Of my 84 blogs, 60 of them had absolutely nothing to do with school or work. Of the 24 that mentioned it, only some of them were actually focused on it--others may have mentioned it in passing, like if I was listing things that annoyed me that day and wrote without any elaboration that students were annoying that day." Where are we going & why are we in this handbasket: Bloggate
In a country that has a multitude of IP addresses, emails, blogs, computer systems, surely it isn't a surprise to find out that a few teachers have blogs...and, god forbid, have blogged about their students?
One need only look at my facebook page to find comments much more sarcastic...and much more profane than the comments Munroe posted on her blog. (No, I won't give you the link. Check your own facebook.) In addition, I will freely name places, people, and events, and I'll probably post links to things that piss me off.
Natalie Munroe blogged under the name "Natalie M", mentioned no students by name, didn't mention her school...but remains suspended from teaching as the Internet debates rage on.
I'm coming back to teaching issues later this...week...(Jeez, it's already Thursday) because in Wisconsin, there's another issue that's even nearer and dearer to my heart. And eventually I'll comment on how not only are we making war on two fronts at once, but one of those fronts is a concept. And how this takes money away from making your children almost bearable.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)